Best Coffee 2027: Italy’s Blind-Tasting Guide Winners

Best Coffee 2027: Italy's Blind-Tasting Guide Winners

Best Coffee 2027: Italy’s Blind-Tasting Guide Winners

Best Coffee 2027: Italy's Blind-Tasting Guide Winners

What if the best cup of coffee in Italy in 2027 is not poured in Naples or Milan, but in a small seaside town most travelers have never typed into a map app? That is exactly what happened when the country’s most closely watched coffee guide handed out its top café award. The result surprised people who assume great espresso only comes from the famous old cities. It also says a lot about where coffee quality is heading as the 2027 guides land on shelves.

Why the 2027 Coffee Guides Matter More Than Usual

Coffee awards are everywhere, but a few carry real weight because of how the judging works. The fifth edition of the Guida dei Caffè e delle Torrefazioni d’Italia 2027, edited by Andrej Godina and Mauro Illiano and published by Bibliotheca Culinaria, reviewed 400 coffee references through blind tastings. A panel of professionals judged every sample without knowing the brand, following strict protocols that govern extraction, equipment, recipes and even water quality. That method removes the marketing gloss and leaves only what is in the cup.

The project is large: the guide profiles 210 roasting companies and, as a new feature this edition, lists 218 cafés where coffee becomes an experience. Scores use Macinini (little grinders): one means a good coffee, two an excellent one, three an outstanding one. Of the 400 references tasted, 170 earned the maximum three Macinini, 203 received two, and 27 received one. Those counts show a crowded top tier, so one award no longer guarantees a rare coffee. Read the category, not the badge alone.

A second major guide, from Gambero Rosso and produced with Illycaffè, crowned Caffè Gilli in Florence as Bar of the Year 2027. Gilli beat four finalists: Caffè Vatta in Trieste, Pasticceria Sartori in Erba, Gran Caffè Quadri in Venice, and Ritorno in Acerra. Judges praised the historic Florentine venue for protecting its identity while still innovating in pastry and mixology. Two guides, two very different winners, and that gap is the real story of the year.

The Surprise Winner: Staccoli Caffè in Cattolica

The Surprise Winner: Staccoli Caffè in Cattolica

The headline result from the Guida dei Caffè 2027 was Caffetteria dell’anno going to Staccoli Caffè in Cattolica, a town on the Romagna Riviera. According to coverage of the awards, the win upended the easy assumption that Naples or Milan would take the top café prize. Those two cities did collect honors, just in other categories.

The remaining café awards spread across four regions, which shows how decentralized Italian coffee excellence has become:

Award Winner City
Caffetteria dell’anno Staccoli Caffè Cattolica (Rimini)
Caffetteria storica Caffè San Carlo Turin
Caffetteria Specialty Cafezal Brera Milan
Caffetteria rivelazione Caffè Diaz Naples
Caffetteria su ruote (outside the guide) Il Caffettiere Errante Otranto

In Emilia-Romagna, the regional sweep was broader still. Gourmet in Imola took the “rivelazione dell’anno” title, the home-roasting category went to capsule giant Caffitaly of Gaggio Montano, and a special mention for the best menu went to the renovated Caffè Pascucci in Marina Centro, Rimini. If you are planning a coffee trip, this list is a more useful starting point than any generic “top ten cafés” article, because every name survived blind tasting or on-site judging.

What Three Macinini Actually Tell You About a Bean

Here is where many buyers go wrong. They see a three-Macinini sticker and assume every bag from that roaster is elite. In practice, the score attaches to a specific reference, not the whole company. A roaster can have one blend at the top and several at two Macinini. Check the exact product name before you pay a premium.

The Julius Meinl results illustrate this well. The Viennese brand collected five awards in the 2027 guide, two of them at the maximum score. In the Espresso category, Belvedere Blend (100% Arabica) and Gloriette Gold (Arabica and Robusta) both earned Three Macinini. Poesia, also an Arabica-Robusta blend, took Two Macinini. Same roaster, same shelves, three different scores. That is the guide working as intended: it rewards the cup, not the logo.

Practical tips for using these scores:

  • Match the score to the brewing method. A blend tuned for espresso may taste flat in a pour-over, and a bright filter roast can turn harsh under pressure.

  • Buy the smallest bag first. Blind-tasting panels are calibrated; your kitchen is not. Test before committing to a kilo.

  • Note the harvest and roast date. A top score from a past edition says nothing about the bag in front of you today.

  • Ignore the “three Macinini” claim if it appears on packaging without a specific product name attached. Vague badges are marketing, not verification.

A common mistake is treating the guide as a shopping list for gifts. It works better as a filter: pick two or three references in your preferred style, compare them side by side, and let your own palate break the tie.

The Roasters Behind the 2027 Shortlists

Beyond Italy, the American trade magazine Roast announced seven finalists for its 2027 Roaster of the Year award, split into micro (under 100,000 pounds roasted annually) and macro divisions. The micro finalists were all US companies: Chocolate Fish Coffee Roasters in Sacramento, Dessert Oasis Coffee Roasters in Farmdale, Michigan, and Idle Hands Roasting Co. in Salt Lake City, among others. The winner was set to be revealed in October and featured in the magazine’s November-December issue.

What stands out in these shortlists is how much weight sustainability and staff training now carry. Chocolate Fish has donated more than 200,000 pounds of compostable material since 2014 and roasts on infrared-burner machines. Dessert Oasis runs an internal education department and uses electric vans for deliveries. Idle Hands sends the large majority of its output to wholesale partners. For a home buyer, this is a useful signal: a roaster that invests in training and logistics usually ships fresher coffee with more consistent results.

If you also follow technology and product rankings, the same “read the methodology” instinct applies to other 2027 buying guides, whether you are comparing the 10 best AI chatbots, GPT-5 and Claude under the hood in 2027 or checking what Toyota Tacoma 2027 buyers can realistically expect. The pattern is identical: the label matters less than the test behind it.

Europe’s Best Coffee Shops and the Global Picture

Italy does not hold a monopoly on great coffee in 2027. A ranking of Europe’s 100 best coffee shops placed Tim Wendelboe in Oslo at the top of the continent. The highest-ranked English entry was Rosslyn, a small London chain with nine outlets in the City, which came 12th overall in Europe and earned the right to compete in the World’s 100 Best Coffee Shops 2027 list. Its co-founder and CEO, James Hennebry, noted that the City of London has one of the richest coffee histories in the world, dating back to the 1600s.

That historical detail is more than trivia. London’s coffee houses were commercial hubs long before espresso machines existed, and the city’s modern specialty scene leans heavily on filter brewing and light roasts, the opposite pole from Italian espresso tradition. For a traveler building a 2027 coffee itinerary, the contrast is the attraction: a three-Macinini espresso in Cattolica and a Nordic-style filter cup in Oslo are answering different questions about what coffee should taste like.

How to Judge Coffee Yourself in 2027

The guides are useful, but they cannot taste for you. Here is a routine that mirrors what professional panels do, adapted for a normal kitchen.

Start with water. The Italian protocols explicitly regulate water quality, and for good reason: hard water mutes acidity, while overly soft water makes coffee taste thin. Filtered tap water is usually enough.

Then control your recipe. Fix the dose, the grind and the brew time, and change only one variable at a time. If you switch beans and grind settings together, you learn nothing.

Finally, taste blind when you can. Ask someone to label two cups A and B and write down which you prefer before you see the bags. Most people discover their favorite is not the most expensive one. That single habit does more for your coffee than any award sticker.

Hobbyists who track rankings across categories tend to enjoy the same exercise elsewhere, from the 2027 recruiting rankings board that looks like a moving target to the movies 2027 release calendar and what’s still unsettled. Rankings shift, and the reasons behind the shifts are usually more interesting than the numbers.

Common Mistakes Buyers Make With 2027 Coffee Awards

A few traps show up again and again.

Confusing café awards with bean awards. Staccoli won as a café, not necessarily for a retail bag. If you want to brew at home, look at the roaster rankings instead.

Assuming a famous city guarantees quality. The 2027 results put the top café in Cattolica, not Naples. Reputation travels slower than quality.

Buying the biggest bag of a winning blend. Freshness beats prestige. A two-Macinini coffee roasted last week will usually outperform a three-Macinini bag that has sat for months.

Ignoring the category. Espresso, moka and filter preparations are judged separately, and a blend built for one can disappoint in another. Read the label’s intended method before you buy.

Treating one guide as gospel. The Guida dei Caffè and Gambero Rosso picked different winners using different criteria. Overlap between the two is a stronger signal than either alone.

Conclusion

The best coffee of 2027 is not a single bag or a single bar. It is a shortlist built from blind tastings, on-site judging and a bit of curiosity. The Guida dei Caffè e delle Torrefazioni d’Italia 2027 gives you 170 references at the top score, 218 cafés to visit and a surprise champion in Cattolica. Gambero Rosso gives you a Florentine institution worth a detour. Europe’s rankings add Oslo and London to the map. Use all of it as a filter, taste side by side, and trust the cup in front of you over the sticker on the shelf. That is how the people who write these guides do it, and it works.

What is the best coffee in 2027 according to the Italian guide?

The Guida dei Caffè e delle Torrefazioni d’Italia 2027 does not name a single best coffee. It awarded its maximum Three Macinini score to 170 of the 400 references tasted blind. Among them are Julius Meinl’s Belvedere Blend and Gloriette Gold in the espresso category. The guide’s top café honor went to Staccoli Caffè in Cattolica.

Who won Caffetteria dell’anno in the 2027 Guida dei Caffè?

Staccoli Caffè in Cattolica, on the Romagna Riviera, took the Caffetteria dell’anno title. It beat the expectation that Naples or Milan would win. Those cities still collected awards: Caffè Diaz in Naples was named Caffetteria rivelazione, and Cafezal Brera in Milan won Caffetteria Specialty.

What do the Macinini scores mean?

The Macinini scale runs from one to three grinders. One means a good coffee, two means excellent, and three means outstanding. In the 2027 edition, 170 references reached three Macinini, 203 received two, and 27 received one. The score applies to a specific product, not to a roaster’s entire range.

Which bar did Gambero Rosso name Bar of the Year 2027?

Gambero Rosso, working with Illycaffè, named Caffè Gilli in Florence as Bar of the Year 2027. It beat four finalists: Caffè Vatta in Trieste, Pasticceria Sartori in Erba, Gran Caffè Quadri in Venice, and Ritorno in Acerra. Judges highlighted its balance of tradition and innovation.

What is the best coffee shop in Europe for 2027?

A ranking of Europe’s 100 best coffee shops placed Tim Wendelboe in Oslo at number one. The top English entry was Rosslyn, a nine-outlet chain in the City of London, which ranked 12th in Europe and qualified to compete in the World’s 100 Best Coffee Shops 2027 list.

How should a home buyer use these 2027 coffee rankings?

Treat them as a filter, not a shopping list. Confirm the exact product that earned the score, buy a small bag first, check the roast date, and match the blend to your brewing method. Tasting two candidates blind at home will tell you more about your own preference than any award badge can.

on this page