Quick Answer: What questions should I ask a Shopify development company before hiring?
Ask about their technical track record, their process for handling your data and code, and what happens after launch. A serious agency will explain which Shopify API version they build against, how they test performance and accessibility, and who owns the finished work. The answers separate real specialists from generalist web shops that list Shopify as one of a dozen platforms.
Agencies differ widely in scope. Some handle only theme customization, others build custom apps or manage migrations from WooCommerce and Magento, and Shopify Plus work is a separate specialty with its own APIs and checkout rules. Compare portfolio depth, communication style, contract terms, maintenance pricing, and post-launch support before signing anything.
Why the First Conversation Matters More Than the Proposal

A polished proposal can hide a thin team. The questions you ask in the first call reveal how the company actually works. Do they talk about API versions and theme architecture, or do they talk only about “beautiful design”? Do they ask about your catalog size and traffic patterns, or jump straight to a price?
Shopify is not a simple platform once you go past a basic theme install. Online Store 2.0, launched in mid-2021, changed how themes are built, with sections everywhere and app blocks. API versions ship roughly quarterly and old ones get deprecated on a published schedule. A partner who cannot speak to these details will hand you a store that ages badly.
The stakes are practical. A slow store loses sales. A store built on a deprecated API breaks quietly. A store whose code you do not own becomes a hostage situation when you want to switch agencies. The questions below are designed to surface all three risks before money changes hands.
Questions About Technical Competence
Which Shopify API version do you build against, and how do you handle upgrades?
This is the single best filter question. Shopify releases new API versions on a regular cadence and retires old ones on a schedule. An agency that answers vaguely is telling you they do not track deprecations. A good answer names a current version and describes a maintenance routine.
Can you explain Online Store 2.0 and theme architecture?
Since 2021, Shopify themes have used a JSON template structure with sections available on every page and app blocks that let merchants drag app features into place. If the company still builds in the old Liquid-only style, you will lose flexibility later. Ask them to walk through how they structure a theme for a merchant who wants to edit pages without a developer.
Do you build custom apps, and do you understand app review rules?
Custom apps for a single store and public apps listed in the Shopify App Store face different requirements. Public apps must pass Shopify’s review process, which has tightened repeatedly over the past few years. If your project needs a private integration, ask how they scope it and what happens when Shopify changes the API it depends on.
How do you test performance?
Google’s Core Web Vitals are the standard here. Interaction to Next Paint replaced First Input Delay as a Core Web Vital in March 2024, so any agency quoting old metrics is behind. Ask for before-and-after numbers from a real project, not a lighthouse screenshot from a demo store.
What is your accessibility process?
WCAG 2.2 became a formal W3C Recommendation on 5 October 2023. Accessibility is a legal issue in many markets and a conversion issue everywhere. Ask whether they test against WCAG conformance levels, whether they run automated and manual checks, and who fixes issues found after launch.
Questions About Process and Communication
Who will actually do the work?
Sales teams close deals; developers build stores. Ask to meet the person who will write the code. Ask how many projects that person handles at once. Agencies that route everything through an account manager and never let you talk to the builder tend to produce surprises.
What does your project timeline look like, milestone by milestone?
Request a schedule with named phases: discovery, design, build, QA, launch. A store build that runs past launch without a documented QA phase is a red flag. Ask what happens if a third-party app turns out to be incompatible mid-build.
How do you handle feedback rounds?
Unlimited revisions sounds generous and usually is not. Ask how many structured feedback rounds are included, what counts as a revision versus a scope change, and how change requests get priced. This one question prevents most contract disputes.
Do you use Shopify CLI and a Git workflow?
Version control is not optional for serious development. Shopify’s command-line tools and Git-based theme workflows let teams test changes safely and roll back mistakes. If the answer is “we edit directly in the theme editor,” walk away.
Questions About Ownership, Data, and Contracts
Who owns the code and the store when we part ways?
You should own your store, your theme, your custom app code, and your customer data. Get this in writing. Ask what happens to repositories, credentials, and documentation on termination. Some agencies retain admin access “for maintenance,” which is a lock-in tactic dressed as service.
How do you handle customer data and privacy?
If you sell to EU or UK customers, GDPR and UK GDPR apply; GDPR has been in force since 25 May 2018. California’s CCPA, updated by the CPRA effective 1 January 2023, covers another large market. Ask how the agency handles cookies, consent tools, analytics, and data access during the build. A partner who has never thought about this is a liability.
What is your migration experience?
Moving from WooCommerce, Magento, or BigCommerce involves URL mapping, redirect planning, and data cleanup. Ask for a migration case study with traffic and ranking outcomes after launch. Migrations are where SEO gets destroyed quietly, and recovery takes months.
What does maintenance cost after launch?
Ongoing support is where budgets quietly drain. Ask for a written maintenance scope: what is covered, response times, hourly rates for out-of-scope work, and whether updates to Shopify’s platform are included. Compare this against what other vendors charge; the pattern is familiar in other procurement decisions, much like the fine print in a Fidelity money market funds guide for savers where the headline rate rarely tells the whole story.
Questions About Security and Platform Fit
Security deserves its own conversation, especially if you plan to add AI chat tools or handle sensitive customer interactions. Ask how the agency vets third-party apps, who has admin access, and whether they enforce two-factor authentication on staff accounts. The same discipline applies when evaluating tools that touch customer conversations; the AI chatbot security questions buyers should ask overlap heavily with the app-vetting questions you should put to your development partner. If the agency also offers monitoring or incident response, run their claims through a managed detection response checklist before trusting them with production access.
Platform fit matters too. Shopify Plus is a separate enterprise tier with different APIs, checkout extensibility, and support terms than standard Shopify. If your revenue or roadmap points toward Plus, ask whether the agency has shipped Plus projects and understands the upgrade path. An agency that has only built standard stores will learn on your budget.
How to Compare Agencies Side by Side
Once you have answers, put them in a table. The exercise forces clarity and exposes gaps fast.
| Question | Strong Answer | Weak Answer |
|---|---|---|
| API version | Names a current version and upgrade process | “We handle all that” |
| Code ownership | You own repos and data, in writing | Vague or silent on termination |
| Performance | Real Core Web Vitals data from past projects | Screenshots from demo stores |
| Accessibility | WCAG 2.2 testing, manual plus automated | “We care about accessibility” |
| Maintenance | Written scope with rates and response times | Hourly billing with no cap |
| References | Two or three clients you can call | Logos only, no contacts |
A pattern shows up in this kind of comparison across many buying decisions. Reviews and checklists exist precisely because marketing copy and reality diverge; a Rillabox review for buyers makes the same point about reading past the sales page. Even consumer purchases follow the rule, as anyone reading an Air Jordan 3 Pure Money buyer’s guide or an Air Jordan 4 Pure Money buyer’s guide will tell you: verify the seller before you pay.
Common Mistakes Buyers Make
The most frequent error is hiring on price alone. The cheapest quote usually excludes QA, migration redirects, and post-launch fixes, all of which appear later as change orders. The second mistake is skipping reference calls. A fifteen-minute conversation with a past client reveals more than any portfolio page. The third is signing without a termination clause. The fourth is assuming “Shopify Partner” status means vetted quality; partner tiers reflect program criteria that Shopify has revised more than once, not a quality guarantee, so treat the directory as a starting point rather than a verdict.
What Actually Works in Practice
Experienced buyers run a short paid discovery before committing to a full build. A small fixed-fee scoping phase produces a technical plan, an architecture note, and a timeline you can compare across vendors. It also tests whether the agency communicates well under a low-stakes deadline. Ask for the discovery output as a deliverable you own.
Another practical habit: request a staging store walkthrough. Watching a developer navigate their own build tells you more about code quality than any slide deck. And keep a written question log. Send the same questions to every candidate, score the answers, and let the comparison do the deciding.
Conclusion
The right Shopify development partner answers technical questions with specifics, puts ownership and data terms in writing, and treats maintenance as a defined service rather than an open tab. The wrong one talks about design and deflects the rest. Prepare your question list, ask every candidate the same things, call references, and compare answers in a table before signing. The hour you spend vetting saves months of cleanup later.
FAQ
How many questions should I ask a Shopify development company?
Aim for fifteen to twenty across four areas: technical competence, process, ownership and data, and post-launch support. More than that becomes an interrogation; fewer leaves blind spots. The goal is comparable answers across vendors, not volume.
Is Shopify Partner status a quality guarantee?
No. Partner status mainly means the company holds an account in Shopify’s partner program. Tiers reflect criteria Shopify sets and has revised over time. Use the partner directory to build a shortlist, then verify quality through references, code samples, and the questions above.
Should I hire an agency or a freelancer for a Shopify build?
Freelancers suit small theme tweaks and tight budgets. Agencies suit multi-phase builds, migrations, custom apps, and Shopify Plus work where you need several specialists and coverage if one person leaves. Match the choice to project complexity, not to price alone.
How long does a typical Shopify store build take?
A theme customization can take a few weeks. A full custom build with migration usually runs two to four months depending on catalog size, app integrations, and content readiness. Ask for a milestone schedule and treat any quote without one as incomplete.
What should a Shopify maintenance contract include?
It should define covered tasks, response times, hourly rates for out-of-scope work, platform update handling, and a cancellation process. Ask whether backups and security monitoring are included, and get the scope in writing before launch day.
Can I switch development companies later?
Yes, if you planned for it. Insist on code ownership, repository access, and documentation at handover. Stores that break during an agency switch almost always lacked these terms from day one, and rebuilding trust in a new partner costs time and money.


