Proton Pass vs 1Password: Pricing and Features Compared

A free option and a polished paid alternative can both be good choices, but they solve different problems. When online accounts pile up, your password manager shapes how you sign in and protect private details. The decision can affect your budget, privacy, and everyday login habits.

Proton Pass appeals to people who want a privacy-oriented option and a permanent free plan. 1Password suits people who value mature organization and convenience. Both can help you manage credentials, but their tools and account designs differ.

This comparison looks at cost, security, features, ease of use, and account recovery. You will see which service fits common needs, plus when another option may deserve a look. The right choice is the one whose protections and daily features match how you actually manage accounts.

Key Takeaways

• Proton Pass has a continuing free plan for core password storage.
• 1Password suits people who want organized vaults and Travel Mode.
• Both services use AES-256 encryption and zero-knowledge protection.
• Proton Pass includes email aliases, while 1Password has a Secret Key.
• Choose based on your routine, budget, and account recovery plan.

Proton Pass vs 1Password: Which Fits Your Priorities?

For a privacy-conscious user who wants a no-cost starting point, Proton Pass is the clearest fit; for a user who values polished organization, start with 1Password. Your daily needs matter more than a blanket claim about the best password managers.

Neither service is a universal winner. Proton Pass is the stronger starting point for a budget-conscious solo user, while 1Password better fits someone who values organized vaults and account protections.

Pick the service whose protections you can use consistently, not the one with the longest feature list.

Proton Pass puts privacy tools and a free starting point near the center of its offer. It can suit someone who wants to secure logins without adding another subscription.

1Password focuses on structured vault organization and a more guarded account sign-in. Its Secret Key and Travel Mode can matter to people who manage sensitive records or travel with devices.

For a quick decision, consider how you handle accounts now. A solo user who mainly needs logins may favor simplicity and low cost.

A household or frequent traveler may value clear vault groups and tools for temporarily removing selected information. Those needs can outweigh the appeal of a free tier.

Someone comparing Proton Pass vs 1Password in 2026 should treat each as a strong choice for different priorities. Use that priority-based verdict as a filter, not as a substitute for checking the features you will rely on every day.

What Do Proton Pass and 1Password Cost?

The entry paid prices are close, but Proton Unlimited is a broader services bundle rather than just a password manager. The listed Proton rates apply when billed annually, so the full yearly charge matters.

Proton Pass Plus costs $35.88 every 12 months, while Proton Unlimited costs $119.88 every 12 months. Their monthly figures show the annual cost divided across the year, not a monthly-billing price.

Pass Plus is a paid plan for people who want more than the basic service. The listed rate is Proton Pass Plus at $2.99 per month with annual billing.

Proton Unlimited combines several Proton services in one plan. It includes Proton Pass, Proton Mail, Proton Calendar, Proton VPN, and Proton Drive.

That bundle makes sense when you would use more than the password manager. If you only need credential storage, the added services may not earn their place in your budget.

1Password’s individual and family premium plans start at the same stated monthly rate in this comparison. The family price is not listed here, so avoid assuming the individual amount applies to a household.

Compare the annual total with the services you will genuinely use, not just the monthly figure.

What Does Proton Pass Free Include?

Yes, Proton Pass has a continuing free plan, not just a short trial. It costs $0.00 per month and supports core credential storage for people who do not want another bill.

The free tier includes unlimited logins and devices, plus notes, credit cards, and 10 hide-my-email aliases. That makes it usable as a lasting plan, not only a way to test the app.

• Unlimited logins, notes, and credit cards
• Access on unlimited devices
• 10 hide-my-email aliases
• $0.00 monthly cost

People asking whether Proton Pass is free can use the service without paying, though upgrades add extra protections and features. Core storage can be enough if you mainly want to replace reused or saved-in-browser passwords.

With unlimited devices, you can use the same account on a computer and phone. That helps when you sign in from more than one place during a normal week.

1Password offers a 14-day free trial rather than a continuing free plan. Once that trial ends, it does not provide a permanent free tier for ongoing use.

Proton Pass Free has also been recognized among password managers for security, with its free access and device coverage as useful points of comparison.

Someone who only needs core credential storage can begin without a subscription and reassess after using the app.

What Can You Store in Each Vault?

A password vault can hold far more than website logins, including records that would be risky to leave in an unprotected note. A vault is a stored collection of credentials and secure information, so one private place can hold several kinds of records.

1Password says information in its vault is encrypted and accessible only by the user. An encrypted vault reduces exposure, but it does not remove the need to secure the account that opens it.

Credentials and sensitive records

Login credentials include usernames and passwords for websites and apps. Other records may be just as sensitive, even though they do not help you sign in.

1Password supports Social Security numbers, secure notes, medical records, and bank-account details. It can also hold identity information and passport details.

That makes a vault useful for records you may need to find quickly, such as a medical detail or a bank account number. It also means a single account can guard more than passwords.

Documents and payment details

1Password can store credit-card details, documents, and software licenses. An individual account includes 1GB of secure document storage.

Its guide to storing credit cards and addresses covers payment details and identity records that can autofill in supported places.

For example, you might keep a passport record beside a travel login, or save a software license with the account that uses it. These records should still be limited to what you need.

A Social Security number can go in an encrypted vault, but treat it as highly sensitive information. Keep only information you need there, and protect the account that unlocks the entire collection.

How Do Their Security Models Compare?

Both products protect stored credentials with AES-256 and zero-knowledge architecture, while 1Password adds a separate Secret Key to vault access. Zero-knowledge encryption means the provider cannot read the contents of your stored vault.

Both services offer strong encryption, but they use different account credentials to protect access. Proton Pass uses end-to-end, zero-knowledge encryption for passwords, passkeys, and credit cards.

Encryption and zero-knowledge protection

AES-256 is a widely used way to encrypt stored data. Both services use it, and both rely on zero-knowledge architecture to protect vault contents.

Proton Pass specifically uses end-to-end, zero-knowledge encryption for passwords, passkeys, and credit cards. These protections help keep stored items private from the provider.

Zero-knowledge designs also make account access important. If you lose the information needed to unlock a vault, getting back in can be harder.

A plain-language explanation of zero-knowledge encryption can help show why a provider cannot read protected files or vault data.

Secret Key and account access

1Password uses a master password and a 34-character Secret Key to protect vault access. The Secret Key is a separate credential, so it adds another layer to the account design.

That extra credential also creates a task: you need to keep it safe and available when signing in. Proton Pass instead uses Proton account credentials for access.

These are two strong approaches, not proof that one service is categorically safer. Choose the architecture you can manage reliably, since losing a required account credential can become a practical security problem.

How Do Privacy and Security Track Records Differ?

Proton Pass’s open-source and independently audited code gives users a way to scrutinize its implementation, while incident reports need careful interpretation. Reviewable code is a useful trust signal, though it cannot guarantee flawless software.

Proton Pass is open source and independently audited, while reported 1Password events have not been described as confirmed vault breaches. Each event needs to be judged by what happened and what the company said.

Transparency and independent review

Open-source code lets outside experts inspect how software works. Independent audits add another form of review, since auditors can look for security problems.

Neither practice proves that every part of an app is free from bugs. Software changes over time, so scrutiny is a helpful signal rather than a promise of perfect safety.

For you, the practical question is whether the product pairs a clear security design with good account habits. Strong account protection still matters even when code receives outside review.

What the reported 1Password incidents involved

In September 2023, 1Password detected and stopped an intrusion into its Okta tenant. The company said user data and password vaults were not compromised.

In August 2024, 1Password released macOS app version 8.10.38 to fix a vulnerability affecting versions before 8.10.36. It said it had no evidence that anyone exploited the flaw.

In March 2025, users reported phishing emails that impersonated 1Password Watchtower alerts. 1Password said the emails did not result from a breach of its systems.

Those events involved a stopped intrusion, a patched app flaw, and impersonation emails. They are distinct from a confirmed compromise of user vaults.

Treat phishing messages as a reason to verify alerts through the app or a trusted address, not by following an unsolicited link.

Which App Feels Easier Across Devices?

Both services cover the major desktop and mobile platforms, so compatibility alone is unlikely to decide the comparison for most users. Daily fit depends more on how well the apps work with your devices and sign-in habits.

Proton Pass and 1Password both support Windows, macOS, Linux, iOS, and Android. Proton Pass also runs in major browsers.

Supported computers and phones

The shared platform list covers the systems most people use at home and work. Proton Pass adds browser access on major browsers, which can matter if you switch computers often.

1Password lists system requirements for its apps and browser support. Its system requirements page details supported operating systems and browser versions.

Having an app for your device is only the first check. Autofill can behave differently across browsers, websites, and phone apps.

Matching the app to your routine

Try the browser extension on a site you use every day. Then test the mobile autofill flow on a common app, such as email or banking.

Pay attention to whether the app recognizes the right login and fills the fields you expect. A smooth sign-in flow can matter more than a long list of supported systems.

Test the sign-in flow on one desktop browser and one phone before moving every credential.

Which Extras Matter in Daily Use?

For inbox privacy, Proton Pass offers aliases; for temporarily hiding selected vaults on a trip, 1Password has Travel Mode. These features address different needs, so your habits should guide the choice.

Email aliases hide your real address, while Travel Mode temporarily removes selected vaults from devices. Neither feature replaces a strong account password or careful sign-in habits.

Protecting your real email address

Proton Pass email aliases forward incoming messages to your real inbox. You can give an alias to an online account instead of sharing your main address.

The free plan includes 10 aliases, while Pass Plus includes unlimited aliases. If an alias begins attracting unwanted messages, you can disable it without changing your real inbox address.

This can help separate sign-ups from personal mail. It also gives you a way to cut off a troublesome address without closing your main email account.

Keeping selected vaults off a travel device

1Password Travel Mode temporarily removes selected sensitive vaults from devices while the mode is active. It can matter when crossing a border with a phone or laptop.

The tool lets you mark vaults for removal before travel and restore them after Travel Mode ends. It is designed for chosen vaults, rather than hiding every item in your account.

• Create an alias for an online account to avoid sharing your real address.
• Disable an alias that attracts unwanted messages.
• Mark selected vaults for removal before travel, then restore them after Travel Mode ends.

Before a trip, decide which vaults you would be comfortable having on the device and mark the others for Travel Mode.

How Should You Protect Your Password Manager Account?

The account that unlocks a vault deserves a unique, strong password and a second layer of authentication. One mistake, such as reusing a familiar password, can put more than one account at risk.

Use a unique master password of at least 20 characters, then enable a second factor where available. A password manager protects many accounts, so its own sign-in should get extra care.

Strong unique passwords and passkeys

A unique password limits the damage if another website suffers a breach. A long password is also harder to guess than a short, familiar phrase.

PCMag recommends unique passwords of at least 20 characters with uppercase letters, lowercase letters, numbers, and symbols. A password manager can generate and store one for your account.

Use these checks to protect the account:

• Use a unique master password.
• Generate a long password instead of reusing a familiar one.
• Enable a second factor on the password manager account.
• Use a passkey where supported.

Proton Pass supports passkeys on all devices. A passkey can offer a simpler sign-in method without relying on a password you type each time.

What NIST authentication levels mean

NIST defines three authentication assurance levels: AAL1, AAL2, and AAL3. They describe the strength of an authentication process, not how long your password must be.

AAL1 covers a basic level of confidence in a user’s identity. AAL2 requires control of two distinct authentication factors and a phishing-resistant authentication option.

AAL3 requires two distinct factors and a phishing-resistant authenticator with a non-exportable authentication key. These are standards for assurance, not a rule that every personal account must meet.

Store recovery details separately from the device you use for daily sign-ins.

How Do You Migrate From 1Password to Proton Pass?

The direct route is to export a 1PUX file from the 1Password desktop app and import it through Proton Pass settings. Check the result before you rely on the new vault.

Proton Pass accepts 1Password 1PUX and 1PIF files. Attachments and custom fields deserve a separate check after import, since they may not transfer perfectly.

Export a 1Password file

Use the desktop app to create a 1PUX export. 1Password’s export instructions explain its desktop export options and the file types available.

An export file can contain sensitive account data. Keep it private while you transfer it and remove it when you have checked the new vault.

Import the file into Proton Pass

Follow these steps to move the data:

1. Open the 1Password desktop app.
2. Export the data in 1PUX format.
3. Open Proton Pass Import settings.
4. Choose 1Password (1pux, 1pif) and select the exported file.

Proton Pass can also import 1PIF files, so you can use that format if you already have one. The 1PUX route is the direct option described here.

After import, check several types of entries, including logins and secure notes. Look closely at attachments and custom fields rather than assuming each one transferred intact.

Verify a few critical logins and records before deleting the original vault or export file.

How Do Proton Pass, 1Password, and Bitwarden Compare?

Bitwarden is a relevant third option for a reader who wants open-source software and a low-cost paid tier alongside these two contenders. Its price can appeal to budget-minded users, while its free plan also covers core storage.

Proton Pass and Bitwarden both use AES-256, zero-knowledge architecture, and support passkeys. Their shared foundations make workflow and plan details more useful for choosing between them.

Shared security foundations

Both services use AES-256 encryption and a zero-knowledge design. They also support passkeys, which can change how you sign in to compatible accounts.

Shared security basics do not make the apps identical. Each service has its own features and workflow, so test the tools you would use most.

The free and paid tradeoffs

Both offer free plans with unlimited password storage. Bitwarden Free also stores credit cards and personally identifiable information.

Bitwarden Premium costs $0.83 per month for an individual in this comparison. Proton Pass costs $2.99 per month for its paid plan, so the lower Bitwarden price may appeal if cost is your main concern.

A broader comparison of password managers can help you see how free plans and security features differ across services.

Compare the exact free features you will use before paying for an upgrade.

Which Password Manager Fits Your Situation?

Choose Proton Pass for privacy-oriented value and a free starting point; choose 1Password when organized vault workflows and travel protection matter more. The best password manager for you is one you will use consistently.

Proton Pass suits readers who want privacy tools or the Proton ecosystem, while 1Password suits readers who want structured organization and Travel Mode. Your account protections and daily workflow should shape the final pick.

Pick Proton Pass for privacy and low cost

Proton Pass is a sensible choice when you want a free starting point and privacy features. It may also fit if you already use Proton Mail or other Proton services.

Choose it for no-cost core use if you mainly need a place to store and use logins. It also fits someone who wants aliases as part of a more private email routine.

Pick 1Password for organization and travel

1Password can suit people who prefer a structured set of vaults and value Travel Mode. Its account design may also appeal if you want an extra access credential beyond a master password.

Use these cases as a quick guide:

• Choose Proton Pass for no-cost core use.
• Choose Proton Pass for integrated aliases and privacy features.
• Choose 1Password for structured organization and Travel Mode.
• Consider Bitwarden if a low-cost paid alternative is the deciding factor.

A Proton Pass review should focus on its fit for your routine, not on a claim of hands-on testing. The best password manager for an individual is the one whose everyday workflow and account protections they will consistently use.

Before committing, try the app on the devices and account types you rely on most.

What Should You Know About Recovery and Account Lockout?

Account recovery is part of the security decision, because a well-protected vault is no help if you cannot unlock it. Keep recovery information accessible offline, so a lost device does not leave you without a plan.

1Password provides a printable Emergency Kit, while Proton Pass relies mainly on a recovery phrase. Each approach works only if you can find and use the information when needed.

Keep recovery information usable

1Password’s Emergency Kit can be printed and stored in a secure place. It gives you a physical record of important account details instead of relying only on a device.

Proton Pass relies primarily on a recovery phrase. Keep it somewhere you can reach without opening the vault it protects.

Email recovery has a specific effect in Proton Pass: saved vault items remain locked until you enter the recovery phrase. Restoring access to the account does not by itself unlock those items.

Protect exports and recovery files

Recovery files and exports contain sensitive information. Do not leave them in an unprotected downloads folder or on a shared device.

A file that is easy to find can also be easy for someone else to copy. Store it in a secure place and remove extra copies once they are no longer needed.

Keep a clear record of where you stored recovery details, but do not place the secret itself beside a device you use for daily sign-ins. Confirm that you can find and use your recovery information before relying on the vault for every critical account.

Conclusion

If a free, privacy-focused starting point matters most, begin with Proton Pass; if organized vault management and travel controls matter most, begin with 1Password. Both can protect everyday credentials, but your routine should decide which account design feels manageable.

Start with a small set of everyday logins instead of moving everything at once. Try your preferred option with a few noncritical accounts, then move the rest only after confirming that its workflow suits you.